Encyclopedia
Chabad
By Rabbi Chaim Miller
Family
Planning
a)
Introduction
b)
Economic argument
c)
"Halachic" argument
d)
Issue of marital harmony
e)
Psychological damage caused by family planning
f)
Historical argument
g)
Pleasure from many offspring
h)
Regret at a later date
i)
Involvement of the yetzer ha’ra
j)
Campaign against family planning
k)
Connection to Moshiach
a)
Introduction
"‘When
G-d blesses a Jewish home, the greatest blessing He can give is sons and
daughters whom the parents will raise in the ways of our ancestors, Avrohom and
Sara, following the way of G-d, practicing justice and righteousness.’ True
blessings and health, in both a physical and spiritual sense, with which G-d
blesses a Jewish family, are connected with the family keeping taharas ha’mishpacha
(family purity) and having children. These mitzvos will prevent us from
being affected by the disturbing influences that have been brought into the
world by the absence of taharas ha’mishpacha. Every child who is born
into the family represents a greater blessing for his parents, grandparents and
siblings. The importance of each new child is seen by the fact that the State of
Israel is willing to pay tens of thousands of dollars for each new immigrant.
"Furthermore,
when the child is born, G-d gives the means to sustain him. The child is not a
burden to his parents; this is their son or daughter for whom G-d has provided.
They need not worry about making a living; G-d ‘sustains and provides for all.’
He carries the burden of providing for the father and mother, the son and the
daughter. For a time, He sustains the children through the medium of their
parents. Later on, their sustenance is given to them directly. Even when parents
help their children at an advanced age, the means to do so is given by G-d. The
greatest blessing, privilege and source of satisfaction a family can have is the
opportunity to raise and educate children."
b)
Economic argument
"One
of the arguments is based on concern about economics. After all, maintaining a
large family costs more. A Jew cannot accept such an argument, for he is ‘a
believer, the descendent of a believer’ (Shabbos 97a), who declares his
faith each day (in the grace after meals) that G-d ‘in His kindness,
provides sustenance for the entire world with grace.’ Perhaps they have
mercy on G-d and wish to lighten His burden. Maybe they are afraid that since He
has to provide for the mother and father, it is unfair to ask Him to provide for
the children. They should not worry about how they are going to balance their
budgets, but should leave that to G-d.
"G-d
has no lack of funds, as the verse declares (Chaggai 2:8), ‘The
silver is Mine and the gold is Mine.’ There is no question that if He can
provide for four billion people, He will manage to provide for another little
boy or girl. Parents should lead normal family lives, according to taharas ha’mishpacha
(family purity), granting each woman her conjugal rights, and leave the rest
up to G-d. If He wants to bless them with more children, with many children,
with even more than a minyan, they should gladly accept these blessings
and even pray to G-d for more."
c)
"Halachic" argument
"Others
try to rationalize their behavior with arguments from Jewish law, arguing that
since the mitzva to ‘Be fruitful and multiply’ (Bereishis 1:28)
can be fulfilled by having only two children (c.f. Yevamos 61b; Rambam,
Hilchos Ishus 15:4); a son and a daughter, there is no need to have more.
They may even support their positions with Kabbalistic sources explaining that
the Arizal writes (Likkutei HaShas, Yevamos, Ibid.) that a father and
mother allude to the first two letters of G-d’s name (Yud and Hei)
and a son and a daughter to the second two (Vav and Hei). After
they have completed G-d’s name, why should they have more children?
"These
rationalizations are not even acceptable according to the Kitzur Shulchan
Aruch, and surely not according to Chassidus. Indeed, the second half of the
command ‘Be fruitful and multiply’ is ‘fill the earth and subdue it.’
We must have as many children as necessary to ‘fill the earth.’
"Furthermore,
the order in which topics are mentioned in the Torah is significant. The fact
that this mitzva is the first mitzva, commanded at the very
beginning of the Torah, emphasizes its importance."
d)
Issue of Marital harmony
"This
applies to every Jewish home, even one in which the relationship between the
husband and wife is in need of improvement. The Torah teaches that even a sota
(a woman whose immodest behavior caused her to undergo the test described in the
Torah) is blessed with children if she is found to be innocent of the charges
brought against her.
"There
are those who argue that it is necessary to wait for the relationship between a
husband and wife to reach the highest possible level before having children.
They believe that people should refrain from having children until the
atmosphere in the home is the most refined. The Torah teaches, however, that
even in cases where the relationship is less than perfect, children are a
blessing."
e)
Psychological damage caused by Family Planning
"If
someone has questions about this matter, they can resolve them by looking at
what has happened to couples who have limited the number of their children. This
program has been called a very diplomatic name: family planning. Its proponents
maintain that since every aspect of a person’s life should be planned out in
advance, a plan must also be developed concerning how many children to have and
at which stage of life to have them. On the surface, such a plan may sound
attractive. However, this attractive phraseology covers up a terrible danger,
the nature of which can be appreciated only by examining the effects of family
planning. A look at the results proves dramatically how it has strained
relationships and created emotional hardships between husbands and wives.
"When
the normal process of marital life as decreed by G-d in the Torah is altered,
and altered radically, the peace of the household is bound to be disturbed.
Family planning opposes not only a Torah approach to married life, but a normal
human approach to life. It has caused couples to seek psychotherapy, marriage
counseling, etc. Instead of bringing order into their lives, family planning has
disturbed the order established by G-d in the Torah."
f)
Historical Argument
"If
one has doubts about this issue, let him examine Jewish history and see how our
ancestors lived in the past, before the spiritual darkness that challenges our
generation descended. In all previous generations, Torah Jews believed that
having a large family constituted the greatest possible blessing. However, the
spiritual darkness of the present generation, which allows darkness to be called
light, and light, darkness, has caused the prevailing attitude to change."
g)
Pleasure from many offspring
"We
can all see what a great blessing having children is. The greatest pleasure a
man or woman can have is watching his children grow up and live according to
Torah and mitzvos. Our capacity for pleasure is not satisfied by only one
child, for as our Sages have said regarding desires: ‘Whoever has one hundred
(coins), wants two hundred’ (Koheles Rabba 1:13). The pleasure and
satisfaction we have from one child will make us desire even more. Furthermore,
by having many children we can see a variety of qualities expressed by our
offspring: one child may be devoted to Torah study, a second to prayer, a third
to deeds of kindness."
h)
Regret at a later date
"If
a family limits the amount of children they have, they will regret it later on.
(This statement does not refer to the spiritual consequences such as denial of Olam
HaBa, a portion of the world to come caused by their act that can and
will be corrected by t’shuva, but rather the social and emotional
consequences the parents will later feel.) Eventually children grow up and leave
home, building their own families. Naturally, their parents will want to visit
them, but they cannot remain constant guests in one place. No matter how close
the relationship, the advice of the Book of Proverbs
(25:17), ‘Let your foot be seldom in your neighbor’s house,’ applies
to some degree. The children will have their own affairs and will not appreciate
constant visits by their parents. If parents have many children, there is no
problem, for they are able to divide their visits between them. However, if they
have only one child, they will have to spend much of their time alone, having no
one with whom to speak."
i)
Involvement of the yetzer ha’ra
"All
the arguments for preventing the birth of children – that the family
relationship is not good enough, that there is a possibility they will not
receive a proper education, that the funds to raise them must be secured, have
one source: the yetzer ha’ra (evil inclination).
"The
yetzer ha’ra is very clever. If he would present himself openly,
no Jew would even listen to him. Therefore, he puts on ‘Jewish clothes’ –
a silk sirtuk – and tries to persuade the Jew that it is a mitzva
not to have children. ‘This way,’ he will say, ‘You will have more time to
devote to valuable projects, etc.’ However, we must realize that despite these
devices, the arguments are those of the yetzer ha’ra, and there
is nothing that the yetzer ha’ra wants that is good for a
Jew."
j)
Campaign against family planning
"The
most disturbing factor is that birth control has become acceptable and no one
argues or protests against it. This matter is of great importance, but is often
ignored at conventions and meetings at which Torah-conscious men or women gather
to discuss various issues. Without minimizing the value and importance of the
other topics they discuss, proper attention should be given to this fundamental
matter..."
"N’shei
Chabad must issue the first call to action, publishing it in every country and
language (in a modest and proper manner), proclaiming that the world and all its
particular aspects are controlled by G-d. He gave every Jew the candle of mitzva
and the light of Torah, a Torah of life, which illuminates our daily life. By
following G-d’s mitzvos as brought down in the Shulchan Aruch,
we follow a path of light. In doing so, all plans are left to G-d. In contrast,
family planning destroys a marital relationship, threatens the future of the
Jewish nation, and delays the coming of Moshiach. May it be G-d’s will that
every one of you make a resolution to speak to Jewish women about this matter,
asking them to have mercy on their husbands and on their children, who want
another brother or sister. When they speak from the heart, their words will
enter the heart."
k)
Connection to Moshiach
"Our
Sages explain (Yevamos 62a) that Moshiach will not come until all the
souls have descended into this world. Through having children, the time of his
coming is hastened.
"Every
Jewish woman must appreciate that her behavior can affect the entire world, as
the Rambam (Hil. T’shuva 3:4) says: With one mitzva, every Jew
can bring salvation and deliverance to the entire world."
(Based
on Sichos of Shabbos Parshas Naso 5740 and 17 Sivan 5740; see also Likkutei
Sichos, Vol. 25, p. 35ff.)
|